From—Bek—To—Redford—Subject—The Proposal of Ten Arguments—18 Jan 2013

Premier Alison Redford

Mr Christopher Bek

Government of Alberta

307 Legislature Building

Edmonton AB T5K 2B7

602, 1133 Eighth Avenue SW

Calgary Canada T2P 1J7

403 471-7440

18 January 2013


Dear Premier Redford,

Subject—The Proposal of Ten Arguments

Quotation—Great spirits are always violently opposed by mediocre minds. —Albert Einstein

Introduction.  I am writing to you to present a proposal that I have put together.  For your information I have included Background information as well as my Biography and the top ten arguments list below.  The key paragraph is entitled Proposal.  The following is a list of what is in this paragraphI would like to have government agents and students write essays in response to my ten argumentsAs well I would like to meet with government agents and students to talk about Philosophymagazine.comI  would also like to enlist the services of an executive producer and an assistant to help me with

Background.  The British philosopher and mathematician Alfred Whitehead (1861-1947) once suggested that all philosophy after Plato (427-347 BC) is merely a footnote.  For Plato, philosophy and mathematics were a passionate way of life.  He was obsessed with many things including the idea of transcending the physical world and achieving eternal existence.  Plato used his famous allegory of the cave to illustrate the difference between spurious belief and genuine knowledge—a distinction that lies at the heart of his most important work The Republic.  An allegory is the figurative treatment of one subject under the guise of another.  Imagine prisoners chained inside a cave such that they only see the shadows projected through eternal objects (eg. the Pythagorean Form) onto the wall from the light of the fire behind them.  A prisoner named Socrates breaks free of his chains and climbs out of the cave into daylight.  After a time his eyes adjust to the light and he returns to the cave intending to free the prisoners.  But back inside the cave Socrates now has trouble making out the shadows.  And his obvious attempt at liberation only serves to anger the prisoners for revealing the illusionary nature of their existence.  They become so overwrought with anxiety that they proceed to kill Socrates for it.  I would argue that I am the Plato of our generation.

Biography.  In 1987 I moved to Toronto after graduating from the University of Calgary with a degree in applied mathematics—and found myself working for The Wyatt Company as an actuarial analyst.  In 1989 I moved back to Calgary with The Wyatt Company.  In December 1990 I was back in Calgary during which I was doing a six-month stint in the San Francisco office of The Wyatt Company.  I then bought a house in Crescent Heights located north of downtown Calgary.  In 1993 I qualified as an associate actuary.  Actuaries use math to solve business problems.  In 1995 I left The Wyatt Company and began consulting to TransCanada Pipelines and PetroCanada in developing Monte Carlo simulation models.  In 1998 I began consulting with the CFO and treasurer of Canadian Pacific Limited.  I had fifteen years of solving hard actuarial science and risk management problems.  I developed spreadsheet and database models, and wrote reports.  I also produced the first five essays regarding my theory of one and my website on 1 January 2001.  In 2001 Canadian Pacific Limited broke up into its five subsidiaries and was the beginning of my fall from grace.  With my theory of one (2001) I have united relatively theory (1905) with quantum theory (1925).  As such I have solved the greatest scientific problem of all time.  I freaked out when I presented my theory of one to the government twelve years ago—and nobody cares.  I lost my house in August 2003.  Since then I have spent my time updating my website, and writing essays and letters, and reading from the five hundred books in my library.  Starting on January 2000 I have written thirty-four essays and fifteen letters to the government.  I have also developed the Bernoulli model (ie. an advanced application of portfolio theory) and the four-moment Camus distribution (ie. mean, standard deviation, skewness and kurtosis).

Top Ten Arguments.  I have put forth ten arguments that the government must answer.  The following is the list of the ten arguments that are also discussed in my Philosophymagazine Ten Top Arguments essay which is enclosed with this letter.

One—Argument vs Authority.

Two—The Theory of One.

Three—The Unpardonable Sin.

Four—The Bernoulli Model.

Five—Existentialism vs Bad Behaviorism.

Six—Freewill vs Determinism.

Seven—Ontology vs Organized Religion.

Eight— vs Newspapers.

Nine—The Illusion of Reality.

Ten—Superman vs Everyman.

Proposal.  I would like to meet with government agents and students on a weekly basis.  Government agents are those who are funded by the government (eg. doctors and educators).  I would like to have government agents and students write essays that either accept or challenge my arguments.  I would also like to enlist the services of an executive producer for one-half day per week.  Kent Hehr, MLA would be an excellent choice.  I met with him in his office which is just three blocks from where I live.  I would also like to recruit the services of an assistant for one-half day per week.  Again, an assistant from Kent Hehr’s office would be a superior selection.  The assistant would make appointments for me and would also help with mailing lists as well as helping to market

Conclusion.  Even if my ten arguments are wrong, they are still effectively right because they are most assuredly biting in the right direction.  I will contact you in one month.




Christopher Bek



  Chief Justice Beverley McLachlin

  Supreme Court Building
  301 Wellington Street

  Ottawa ON K1A 0A6



  Right Honourable Stephen Harper

  House of Commons

  Ottawa ON K1A 0A6



    Right Honourable William Clinton

    55 West 125 Street

    New York NY 10027 USA


  Mr Peter Mansbridge

  Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

  PO Box 500 Station A
ON M5W 1E6


  President Elizabeth Cannon

  University of Calgary

  2500 University Drive NW

  Calgary AB T2N 1N4


    Mr Ross Welsh

    347 Crystal Green Rise

    Okotoks AB T1S 2N6

  Governor General David Johnston

  301 Wellington Street

  Rideau Hall

  1 Sussex Drive

  Ottawa ON K1A 0A1




 Dr Gordon Sick

 University of Calgary

 150 Schurfield Hall

 2500 University Drive NW

 Calgary AB T2N 1N4


      Mr Brock McCarten

      344 Springborough Way SW

      Calgary AB T3H 5M7


    Mr Frank Kelton

    Potential Place

    110, 999 Eighth Street SW

    Calgary AB T2R 1J5



   Dr David Gibbs

   Sheldon Chumir Health Centre

   1213 Fourth Street SW

   Calgary AB T2R 0X7



    Dr Nenad Vrbansic

    Eau Claire Dentil Clinic

    229, 200 Barclay SW

    Calgary AB T2P 4R5

  Dr Robert Ian Thompson

  Department of Physics

  University of Calgary
  SB 124 2500 University Drive NW

  Calgary AB T2N 1N4



  Dr Valeri Frolov

  Department of Physics

  University of Alberta
  4-281F Central Centre

  Edmonton AB T6G 2J1




   Dr Thomas Brabec

   Department of Physics

   University of Ottawa
   Macdonald Hall 125

   Ottawa ON K1N 6N5



  Dr Christopher McKee

  Department of Physics

  University of California Berkeley

  Berkeley CA 94720-7300 USA



  Ms Dara Dines

  Canadian Mental Health Association

  400, 1202 Centre Street SE

  Calgary AB T2G 5A5



   Dr Doug Osheroff

   Stanford University
   Room 150 Varian Physics Bldg
   382 Via Pueblo Mall

   Stanford CA 94305-4060 USA


  Dr Eanna Flanagan

  Department of Physics

  Cornell University
  463 Physical Building 606

  Ithaca NY 14853 USA



  Dr Michael Blanton

  Department of Physics

  New York University
  4 Washington Place

  New York NY 10003 USA



   Dr Michael Aizenman

   Department of Physics

   Princeton University

   Princeton NJ 08544 USA



  Dr Michael Smith

  Department of Physics

  Harvard University
  17 Oxford Street

  Cambridge MA 02138 USA



  Dr Nabil Elkabir

  Twelve West Medical Clinic

  130, 227 Eleventh Avenue SW

  Calgary AB T2R 1R9



   Ms Sonya Savage

   Enbridge Inc.

   3000, 425 First Street SW

   Calgary AB T2P 3L8


  Premier Alison Redford

  Government of Alberta

  307 Legislature Building

  Edmonton AB T5K 2B7


  Francine and Roger Kenny

  907, 2914109 Street

  Edmonton Alberta T6J 7E8


   Chief Rick Hanson

   Calgary Police Service

   133 Sixth Avenue SE

   Calgary AB T2G 4Z1

   Ms Karen Davis

   Canadian Mental Health Association

   104, 1133 Eighth Avenue SW

   Calgary AB T2P 1J7


  Mr Shawn Kenny

  2705, 1201 Marinaside Crescent

  Vancouver BC V6Z 2V2


     Mayor Naheed Nenshi

     Office of the Mayor

     #8069 City of Calgary

     PO Box 2100 Station M

     Calgary AB T2P 2M5




  Mr Jack Bannon

  5611 Ladbrooke Drive SW

  Calgary AB T2E 5Y2



  Mr Bart Demosky

  Suncor Energy Inc.

  150 Sixth Avenue SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 3E3

    Mr Philip Dolan

    Talisman Energy Inc.

    3400, 888 Third Street SW

    Calgary Alberta T2P 5C5

  Mr Craig Blackwood

  Advantage Oil & Gas Ltd.

  700, 400 Third Avenue SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 4H2


  Mr Bradley Karst

  ConocoPhillips Canada

  401 Ninth Avenue SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 2H7





    Dr Dennis Mckerlie

    University of Calgary

    SS 1236

    2500 University Drive NW

    Calgary AB T2N 1N4

  Mr Doug Proll

  Canadian Natural Resources Limited

  2500, 855 Second Street SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 4J8


  Mr Garry Lamb

  TransCanada Pipelines Limited

  450 First Street SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 5H1


    Mr Dave Newby

    ConocoPhillips Canada

    401 Ninth Avenue SW

    Calgary Alberta T2P 2H7

  Mr Matt Haney

  Shell Canada Limited

  400 Fourth Avenue SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 0J4



  Mr Greg Kenny

  2614 Triumph Street

  Vancouver BC V5K 1S9

    Mr Garth Renne

    Enmax Corporation

    141 50th Avenue SE

    Calgary Alberta T2G 4S7

  Mr Randy Eresman

  EnCana Corporation

  1800 855 Second Street SW

  Calgary Alberta T2P 5E5


  Ms Amy Williams

  Canadian Mental Health Association

  104, 1133 Eighth Avenue SW

  Calgary AB T2P 1J7


    Ms Kim McKay

    Canadian Natural Resources Limited

    2500 855 Second Street SW

    Calgary Alberta T2P 5C5

   Mr Don Orchard

   Canadian Broadcasting Corporation

   1724 Westmount Boulevard NW

   Calgary Alberta T2N 3G7


    Mr Kent Hehr, MLA

    Calgary-Buffalo Constituency

    #130 1177 Eleventh Avenue SW

    Calgary Alberta T2R 1K9

    Ms Krista Cruickshank

    420 Country Hills Court

    Calgary Alberta T3K 3Z3

   Mr Len Perry

   CTV Television

   80 Patina Rise SW

   Calgary Alberta T3H 2W4



  The Nobel Foundation

  PO Box 5232

  SE-102 45 Stockholm


    Lou and Shirley Beke

    107, 4955 River Road

    Delta BC V4K 4V9


    Alderman John Mar

  700 Macleod Trail SE

  Calgary Alberta T2G 2M3










Quantum theory does not hold undisputed sway, but must share dominion with that other rebel sibling—relativity.  And although these two bodies together have led to the most penetrating advances in the search for knowledge—they must remain enemies.  Their fundamental disagreement will not be resolved until both are subdued by a still more powerful theory that will sweep away our present painfully won fancies concerning such things as space, time, matter, radiation and causality.  The nature of this theory may only be surmised—but it will ultimately come down to the very same certainty as to whether our civilization as a whole survives—no more no less.

—Banesh Hoffmann, The Strange Story of the Quantum (1958)


Relativity asks questions like—Is there a beginning and end to time?  Where is the farthest point in the universe?  What lies beyond the farthest point?  What happened at the point of Creation?  By contrast, quantum theory asks the opposite questions—What is the smallest object in the universe?  Can matter be divided into smaller and smaller units without limit?  In many ways these two theories appear to be exact opposites.  Relativity concerns itself with the universe at large while quantum theory probes the subatomic world.

—Michio Kaku, Beyond Einstein (1995)


Neither relativity nor quantum theory by themselves provides a satisfactory description of nature.  Einstein showed that relativity theory alone cannot form the basis for the unified field theory.  Nor is quantum theory satisfactory without relativity.  Quantum theory can only be used to calculate the behavior of atoms and not the large-scale behavior of galaxies and the expanding universe.  Merging the two theories has consumed the Herculean efforts of scores of theoretical physicists for the past half century.

—Michio Kaku, Beyond Einstein (1995)


If we do discover a complete theory of everything, it should be understandable by everyone and not just a few scientists.  Then we shall all, philosophers, scientists and ordinary people, be able to take part in discussing questions as to why both we and the universe exist.  If we find the answer to that it would be the ultimate triumph of human reason—for then we would at last know the mind of God.

—Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time (1996)


Quantum theory deals with fundamental units of matter and energy.  Relativity deals with space, time and the structure of the universe as a whole.  Both are accepted pillars of modern scientific thought.

—Lincoln Barnett, The Universe and Dr. Einstein (1948)


The final theory of everything will undoubtedly be a mathematical system of uncommon tidiness and rigor that accommodates the physical facts of the universe as we know it.  The mathematical neatness will arrive first followed by its explanatory power.  Perhaps one day physicists will find a theory of such compelling beauty that its truth cannot be denied—truth will be beauty and beauty will be truth.  The theory will be, in precise terms, a myth.  A myth is a story that makes sense on its own terms, offers explanations of everything we see before us, but can neither be disproved nor tested.  This theory of everything will indeed spell the end of physics.  It will be the end not because physics has been able to explain everything, but because physics has at last reached the end of all the things for which it has the power to explain.

—David Lindley, The End of Physics (1993)


I know not what the world thinks of me, but as for myself, I seem to be only a boy playing on the seashore, now and again finding a smoother stone or a more beautiful shell—all the while the great ocean of truth lies undiscovered before me.

—Sir Isaac Newton (1642-1727)


The theory of one brings the reader face to face with the stunning realization that the universe is bounded—rather than unbounded, as Einstein and others have asserted.  The theory of one delivers the ocean.  It is the theory that spells the end of physics.  It is the monolith of 2001—a spacetime odyssey.

—Christopher Bek, The Theory of One (2001)


If this discovery is confirmed, it will surely be one of the most stunning insights into our universe that science has ever uncovered.  Its implications are as far-reaching and awe-inspiring as can be imagined.  Even as it promises answers to some of our oldest questions, it poses others even more fundamental.  We will continue to listen closely to what it has to say as we continue the search for answers and for knowledge that is as old as humanity itself, but essential to our people’s future.

—President William J Clinton






Christopher Bek is a mathematician, actuary, philosopher, scientist and writer—and is a superior spreadsheet, database and riskmodeling craftsman.  He has consulted to the top executives of one of the largest companies in Canada—and has made presentations relating to the philosophy and science of risk management in Houston and New York. Chris founded Risk Management Services in 1995 dedicated to helping executives develop scientific management practices that will allow organizations to properly serve the shareholders, the stakeholders and society in the community.  Socrates (470-399 BC) set the table for Plato (427-347 BC) by radically insisting that we must first answer the question of what X is before we can say anything else about X.  Plato then founded philosophy by daring to ask what existence would be like outside the cave.  Chris founded Philosophymagazine on 1 January 2001 in support of those who have taken a less traveled road in the struggle towards daylight.